Top Ad



No announcement yet.

Setting the hook on bluegill and crappie

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Setting the hook on bluegill and crappie

    Good evening, first time poster here. Had a couple questions.

    When ice fishing for bluegill and crappie- if using live bait do you try to set the hook after a first bite? or wait until the second? I've been waiting for the 2nd and wonder if i'm missing fish. I figured if it was live bait, that jig/wax worm could be in it's mouth while i'm waiting on the 2nd bite? Idk..and do you just raise the pole to set the hook? Thanks in advance.

  • #2
    This is a good question and one that I myself have not come up with a definet answer to yet. I have missed several ‘bites’ while ice fishing and am sure I will continue to do so in the future. Most times if the bobber is taken down with any depth, you can be pretty certain the bait is well in the mouth of the fish. But there are times when fish are not aggressive in their ‘strike’ and the bobber is only slightly moved, it is then difficult to know when to raise the pole to set the hook. With the fear of small fish just taking the bait and not pulling the bobber with any indication of a good strike and thus swallowing the bait and making it very hard to remove the hook without killing the fish, I usually will pull the bait up and away from the fish to prevent that from happening. I use a small tear drop and with these lures, there is very little to grasp in helping to remove the hook and if the bait is taken deep in the mouth and into the gill area, it is most difficult to remove. So I am afraid there is no sure answer to your question, and only experience will possibly give you your own way to decide, as this is a very common situation in ice fishing. I wish you luck in this matter !


    • #3
      My question is what kind of hooks are you using. If your using circle hooks then a lite pull is what your supposed to do. It should hook them in the corner of the mouth. Most of the time they hook themselves. If your using a baitholder then as soon as you feel a good pull then I would set the hook with a decent pull, back. If the fish feels anything out of the ordinary like feeling the hook, then you can miss them waiting. I’ve missed them not waiting and I’ve missed them waiting so your going to miss a couple just a part of fishing. Also a smaller hook size may help.
      Last edited by Solitario Lupo; 02-12-2019, 04:39 PM.


      • #4
        I set the hook as soon as they hit it when I can't see them. For several years now I've spent quite a bit of time ice fishing for panfish in water that is shallow enough I can watch them play with the jig. I haven't found the number of strikes or the amount of time after they hit to be a reliably indicator of whether they have the hook in their mouth. At least when you set the hook right away you don't hook as many in the gills and I don't think you're going to catch fewer fish.

        Missing a bunch of panfish seems to be unavoidable but on days when they're not grabbing the whole bait I switch to a smaller jig without a tail and that seems to help.

        And yes, quickly lifting the rod or snapping your wrist up sets the hook.




        Welcome to Field and Streams's Answers section. Here you will find hunting, fishing, and survival tips from the editors of Field and Stream, as well as recommendations from readers like yourself.

        If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ for information on posting and navigating the forums.

        And don't forget to check out the latest reviews on guns and outdoor gear on

        Right Rail 1


        Top Active Users


        There are no top active users.

        Right Rail 2


        Latest Topics


        • Clan of the Cave Bear
          by MattM37
          Have any of you read this? All I remembered was the cheeseball movie starring Darryl Hannah, but on a whim I grabbed the paperback yesterday from the...
          Today, 07:55 PM
        • Reply to Clan of the Cave Bear
          by FirstBubba
          Just completed "Angels in the Sky" by Robert Gandt.
          How a band of volunteer airmen saved the new state of Israel.

          Today, 09:39 PM
        • Tikka T3x - 300WM - Why 24” 1:11 twist barrel?
          by Gvanwage
          Someone please school me on this!

          I am in the market for a 300 WinMag and totally new to the caliber/cartridge. I love the Look, feel,...
          Yesterday, 01:18 PM
        • Reply to Tikka T3x - 300WM - Why 24” 1:11 twist barrel?
          by PAShooter
          I have read where shooters have had success with 200 gr. Accubonds and 200 gr ELDX in the 1-11 twist Tikka. There are some fine bullets in the 30 caliber...
          Today, 05:10 PM
        • Contaminants
          by MattM37
          How are the waters in your area? Do you get to each much fresh fish?

          Most of my local waters aren't even listed on the state health...
          Today, 04:54 PM

        Right Rail 3


        Footer Ad