Top Ad



No announcement yet.


  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Spawners

    Some anglers object to bass fishing during the spawn, saying that even catch-and-release is harmful since a bass bed can be invaded by perch, rock bass, etc. while the parent fish is off the bed.

    What's your opinion on fishing during the spawn, with bass or any other species?

  • #2
    Catch and release if you're concerned.
    Each female lays thousands and thousands of eggs. It's nature's way of insuring regeneration.
    I wouldn't worry about it a whole lot.
    It wouldn't be a big deal to release half your catch or all the egg laden females.
    The quicker you land them, the less you stress them.
    I think it's a personal choice.


    • #3
      I’d say it depends on the fishery involved. In a backwater setting that gets little pressure I doubt it would make much difference. In a heavily fished lake that gets other stresses as well then maybe not a good idea.

      Tournament fishing gets a bad rap for mortality rates at times, I wouldn’t be surprised if that’s a bigger issue.


      • #4
        Leave them alone until after the spawn.

        What can damage and over fishing do ? Perch limit is now down to 6 fish - unless that was a typo. Years of taking 100 or more plus the Canadians had/have no limit at all and this is what we get. A year of tremendous Walleye and the Perch are almost decimated.


        • #5
          Catch and release has been going on for a few years on Oneida. Last year's catch rates for smallmouth bass were down. I think it has more to do with to much food.

          Gobies have arrived.


          • #6
            All depends on the fish, bass I would let go since they aren’t really stocked and need to spawn for them to be there.

            So now who to believe. Some say catch and release, some say as soon as you catch them the eggs are attacked, and some say the bass never go back to the nest when you catch them.

            With all that that said it’s up to you to make the right decision.




            Welcome to Field and Streams's Answers section. Here you will find hunting, fishing, and survival tips from the editors of Field and Stream, as well as recommendations from readers like yourself.

            If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ for information on posting and navigating the forums.

            And don't forget to check out the latest reviews on guns and outdoor gear on

            Right Rail 1


            Top Active Users


            There are no top active users.

            Right Rail 2


            Latest Topics


            • Reply to Trump
              by bowhunter75richard
              Politics has become a total money issue. The ‘dark money’ that was spent on the biden election was in the hundreds of millions of dollars ! The dimwits...
              Today, 08:45 AM
            • Trump
              by Danbo
              04-17-2020, 06:15 AM
            • Reply to Keepsakes
              by PigHunter
              I have old stuff not considered keepsakes. So I won't list them.

              Keepsakes related to the Outdoors:
              > Dad's squirrel rifle, a Winchester...
              Today, 08:18 AM
            • Keepsakes
              by MattM37
              Other than the obvious mounts and such, what have you kept for keepsakes over the years?

              I have my dad's old pocketknife, the blade honed...
              Yesterday, 07:56 PM
            • Reply to How Big Is It
              by FirstBubba
              jimbo, your Senators are Sherrod (d) and Portman (R).
              Sherrod is a real piece of work. The epitome of a liberal worm.
              Portman is a pretty...
              Today, 08:09 AM

            Right Rail 3


            Footer Ad